Question 62 of 100
AIBE III 2012
Set Common
The rule of School A is that students' pet dogs are not permitted to enter the school's premises. Student B, who is blind, brings his guide dog C into School A. Which of the following Statements is the most accurate application of the principle below?
- A Since Student B is blind, he would not be able to come to school if he cannot bring his guide dog C into School A; since this rule does not intend to bar blind students from attending school, Student B may bring guide dog C into school. Official answer
- B Since the guide dog C is a pet dog in this context, Student B cannot bring guide dog C into School A.
- C Since this rule does not make any sense in this context, it is invalid, and Student B can bring guide dog C into School A.
- D Since Student B is blind, he would not be able to come to school if he cannot bring his guide dog C into School A. However, according to the context rule, Student B must look at the context of the rule and avoid bringing the guide dog C to school as it could hurt other students.
- E The school is required to apply the context rule while deciding each individual case of violation and it will be up to the discretion of the school whether to punish guide dog C for violating the rules of the school.